Breathing difficulties

Help the person get into a comfortable position (usually seated).

A person with breathing difficulty may complain of tightness in the chest or feeling suffocated; they may have very rapid or noisy breathing, or perhaps struggle to inhale. The most important causes that may need first aid are Choking, heart failure (see Unresponsiveness) or an acute episode of a known condition (such as Asthma or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease). Hyperventilation is also a relatively frequent breathing disorder which is usually a consequence of anxiety or being upset and usually passes quickly. In babies and young children, breathing difficulties could also be caused by Croup or bronchiolitis.

Guidelines

  • People with breathing difficulties may experience relief from a comfortable position such as a seated position or an arm bracing position (leaning forward with arms braced and leaning on a support). *
  • A person who is hyperventilating may be reassured. Rebreathing in a paper bag may also help relieve the symptoms. *
    • Good practice points

    • First aid providers may assist the person to take their medication if they have any.
    • If the person is experiencing severe breathing difficulties as well as a change in mental status (such as confusion or drowsiness) the first aid provider should access emergency medical services (EMS) and continue to observe and assist the person until help arrives.
    • In certain cases, a specially trained first aid provider can give supplementary oxygen.
    • If the person’s breathing does not improve after 10–15 minutes, medical care should be considered. 

    Guideline classifications explained

    Chain of survival behaviours

    Prevent and prepare
    • Be aware of any conditions, such as asthma or lung disease, that family, friends, and co-workers have; and how to help them if there is an emergency.
    • If possible, avoid entering places with poisonous gases or smoke without appropriate breathing equipment.
    Early recognition

    Breathing difficulties can be subjective. What may seem severe to one person may not be severe to another. Listen to the person and look for clues in their behaviour and the surrounding environment.

    The person may tell you or indicate that they are having difficulty breathing, or that they have a pre-existing medical condition such as asthma  or lung disease.

    The signs and symptoms a first aid provider may look for to indicate breathing difficulties include:

    • shortness of breath
    • laboured breathing
    • noisy breathing
    • coughing
    • rapid breathing rate (more than 40 breaths per minute in babies; 30 in children; 20 in adults)
    • slow breathing rate (less than 25 breaths per minute in babies; 15 in children; 10 in adults)
    • not being able to count to 10 after one deep breath in
    • use of accessory muscles for breathing (neck, shoulders)
    • movement of nostrils
    • bluish colour to the skin of the lips, ears, fingers and toes.

    Hyperventilation is also characterised by other typical signs and symptoms, such as:

    • dizziness
    • headache
    • sweating
    • tingling sensation in hands, feet, fingers or mouth.

    ______________________________

    NOTE

    Be alert as dangerous gases and other substances can cause breathing difficulties.

    ______________________________

    First aid steps
    Breathing difficulties
    1. Help the person into a comfortable (usually seated) position and reassure them. They may experience relief by sitting leaning forward with arms braced and leaning on a support.
    2. Assist them to take their medication if they have any. Loosen any tight clothing.
    3. Access EMS immediately if:

    >   their medication is ineffective after a couple of minutes
    >   the person is experiencing severe breathing difficulties
    >   the person has a change in mental status, such as confusion, drowsiness or unresponsiveness
    >   their breathing becomes slow
    >   their lips, fingers or ears turn a bluish colour.

    4.  If properly trained and access to supplementary oxygen is available, give it to the person as needed. (See Oxygen administration.)
    5.  Continue to observe the person, keeping them calm and comfortable. Stay with the person until their breathing returns to normal.

     

    Hyperventilating

    If the person is hyperventilating:

    1. Move the person to a quiet place and ask bystanders to keep their distance. If possible, remove the cause of the panic attack.
    2. Comfort the person and act calmly and predictably. Ask them to breathe in and out slowly and steadily into their shell-folded, closed hands or into a paper bag.
    3. Loosen any tight clothing.
    4. Stay with the person until their breathing returns to normal. Once calmed down, let them breathe in ambient air.
    ______________________________
    NOTE

    If the person is unresponsive, open their airway and check for breathing. See Unresponsiveness.

    ______________________________
    Access help
    • In the case of hyperventilation, access EMS if:
      >    the panic attack continues
      >    you suspect that it may not be caused by a panic attack.
    Recovery
    • Following a person’s first episode of breathing difficulties, encourage them to start to recognise the signs of breathing difficulties as early as possible. This is so they can consider taking their medication (if they have any) and to get into the most comfortable position possible or access help if signs are severe.
    • Encourage the person to seek specialised medical care for recurring panic attacks.

    Education considerations

    Context considerations
    • Research has identified that both within and between communities, people may treat breathing difficulties differently. Some communities and individuals wait to seek assistance when in a much more advanced phase of illness (Cartledge et al., 2017).
    • In remote areas, it may be beneficial to drive towards the nearest medical facility and meet the EMS vehicle en-route. First aid programme designers should know the availability and response time of pre-hospital services in their area as these may be limited. Education should emphasise that early recognition of potentially time-critical problems is essential.
    • Tailor education to learner needs according to the environment they are in (for example areas of high air pollution); or if there is a particular situation where breathing difficulties might become apparent (such as during a Pandemic).
    • Non-emergency medical services may be able to treat breathing difficulties that occur slowly and over time. First aid education should include advice about the available options in local health services.
    Learner considerations
    • Educators should be mindful of the cultural, gender and age-based factors that may influence learners’ understanding of breathing difficulties and severity. Ensure first aid programme content is inclusive.
    • Learning about how to recognise and respond to breathing difficulties could benefit carers of older adults who have chronic lung or heart conditions, parents with babies, and caregivers of children with asthma.
    • Learners who spend time in smoky or dusty environments (such as firefighters or construction workers), or in places where there might be chemicals (such as laboratories, factories or farms), could benefit from learning about breathing difficulties.
    Facilitation tips
    • Emphasise the importance of listening to the person’s breathing to help identify any problems that may worsen and result in a medical emergency. Highlight that breathing can deteriorate over time.
    • Re-visit what “normal” breathing looks like by counting breathing rates and regularity.
    • Ask learners to show how they think someone may look or act when experiencing breathing difficulties.
    • Explore learners’ understanding of the term “breathing difficulty”, as well as the causes and their experience with it. They might have different interpretations which could affect their response and willingness to act. For example, people with a specific type of breathing difficulty called orthopnoea have trouble breathing when they lie down, typically at night, and may not seek assistance if they feel they can resolve the symptom by sitting upright.
    • Run scenarios to rehearse recognising and responding to the typical presentation of various types of breathing difficulties. Assessing the scene for hazards should be a part of the exercise.
    • Regarding hyperventilation, explain the purpose of breathing into shell-folded, closed hands or into a paper bag is to develop a normal balance between the amount of oxygen and carbon dioxide in the blood.
    • Explain to learners that someone who is hyperventilating may benefit from following a breathing rhythm. Have learners practise setting an example and encouraging someone to follow their breathing rhythm. This may have a count of one to breathe in through the nose and a count of three to breathe out through the mouth.
    Facilitator tools
    • Use videos to show normal breathing and changes in breathing (e.g., asthma attack), as well as brief clips to demonstrate life-threatening breathing problems.
    • Use scenario-based learning to help individuals integrate assessment skills. (See General approach.)
    • A method of assessing breathing difficulty is to ask the person to take a deep breath and then have them count from 1 to 30, clearly but quickly (Roth Score). If the person cannot count to 10, at most, they have breathing difficulties. Give learners time to practise this method.
    Learning connections
    • Common causes of breathing difficulties include Chest injury, chronic obstructive lung disease, bronchitis, Croup (babies and children) and bronchiolitis (babies and young children).
    • Other life-threatening conditions which result in breathing difficulty include Choking, heart failure (see Unresponsive and abnormal breathing) and Asthma attack.
    • Consider whether it is appropriate for learners to learn about Use of oxygen.
    • Any stressful situation, including ones where first aid for injuries and illness might be required, could cause some people to panic. (See Traumatic event.) Learning how to calm a person who is hyperventilating could be an important part of scene management.

    Scientific foundation

    Systematic reviews

    The Centre for Evidence-Based Practice (CEBaP) completed evidence reviews on shortness of breath and posture, as well as hyperventilation and breathing in a paper bag. The evidence in both studies is of low certainty and results are considered imprecise due to limited sample size and lack of data.

    Shortness of breath and posture

    There is limited evidence from three experimental studies in favour of arm bracing and sitting. 

    A randomised controlled trial showed that arm bracing resulted in a statistically significant decrease of Borg dyspnoea scale . It was compared to leaning forward while standing or erect standing in people with stable chronic obstructive pulmonary disease experiencing shortness of breath (dyspnoea). A statistically significant increase or decrease of Borg dyspnoea score, standing erect compared to leaning forward while standing, could not be demonstrated. In a second randomised controlled trial, it was shown that a sitting position resulted in a statistically significant decrease in Borg dyspnoea score, compared to lying on their back (supine position). In a third trial, a statistically significant change in Borg dyspnoea score, sitting compared to lying on the back (supine), could not be demonstrated. Evidence is of low certainty.
     

    Hyperventilation and breathing in a paper bag

    There is limited evidence from one experimental study in favour of breathing in a paper bag. This study in which 12 healthy volunteers were instructed to hyperventilate deliberately showed that breathing in a paper bag resulted in a statistically significant decrease in time to reach baseline CO₂ levels and time to symptom disappearance, compared to not breathing in a paper bag. A statistically significant decrease in time to symptom disappearance when breathing in a closed-circuit tube system, compared to an open circuit tube system, could not be demonstrated.

    References

    Systematic reviews

    Centre for Evidence-Based Practice, Belgian Red Cross-Flanders. (2020). Evidence summary Hyperventilation – Breathing in a paper bag. Available from https://www.cebap.org/knowledge-dissemination/first-aid-evidence-summaries

    Centre for Evidence-Based Practice, Belgian Red Cross-Flanders. (2019). Evidence summary Dyspnea – Posture. Available from
    https://www.cebap.org/knowledge-dissemination/first-aid-evidence-summaries/

     

    Related topics

    Explore the guidelines

    Published: 15 February 2021

    First aid

    First aid

    Explore the first aid recommendations for more than 50 common illnesses and injuries. You’ll also find techniques for first aid providers and educators on topics such as assessing the scene and good hand hygiene.

    First aid education

    First aid education

    Choose from a selection of some common first aid education contexts and modalities. There are also some education strategy essentials to provide the theory behind our education approach.

    About the guidelines

    About the guidelines

    Here you can find out about the process for developing these Guidelines, and access some tools to help you implement them locally.